I found this online and thought if I put it up it might help people decide which version is better for them! Hope it sorts out any confusion.
Click Here for the list
Thanks to Theresa at Twifans for doing the list
"New Moon" DVD Comparison List
We're getting a lot of emails & tweets and there seems to be a lot of confusion over which dvd has what on it. Because I'm in Ireland and have the Uk Version I'm not much help.
I found this online and thought if I put it up it might help people decide which version is better for them! Hope it sorts out any confusion.
Thanks to Theresa at Twifans for doing the list
I found this online and thought if I put it up it might help people decide which version is better for them! Hope it sorts out any confusion.
Thanks to Theresa at Twifans for doing the list
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
66 comments:
I'm NKhpTwihard on Twifans and on Twitter, and I actually made the chart and posted it at Twifans. To my surprise and delight Summit approved and made a few changes to it, adding some more of Walmart's information. You can see the posting here http://www.twifans.com/profiles/blogs/new-moon-dvd-guidesummit?xg_source=activity
I have to admit I bought both the Wal-mart and Target versions. I liked the Wal-mart version more for some reason. What I did not realize was that Borders also has alot that the other 2 don't have like "Extended" Scenes, Interviews, and Red Carpet so I might pick that one up too...
Great that you put up that list, but what about Bella's Box?? (the scandinavian version). I really need to know if it's worth buying..! :)
Theresa,
thanks for making the chart!
I have the target version & the walmart version will arrive in the mail someday (walmart fail)
might have to pick up the borders version as well for more extras..
I'm not obsessed, right?????
Thanks theresa I'll edit the post and add credit ;-)
I have the Borders version (which kicks ass), the Target version (which is ok) and the Walmart version that is supposed to be at my house today or tomorrow. Yep, I spent $90 on Rob. Worth every cent.
Nice chart Theresa, I saw that Summit had approved it and it is the reason I went to midnight release party at Borders. So thanks a lot! ;-)
I've decided NOT to purchase. Summet should release a 3 or 4 disc with EVERYTHING on it. That is, extended and deleted scene, behind the scenes stuff, as well. Just put it all in 1 convenient package.
So I guess I need to go to borders. Walmart didn't have the deleted scenes but I love the stuff they had like Edward Fast Forward.
Here's the New Moon reunion kiss that we didn't get in the movie or the deleted scenes....boooo Chris..
http://rpattzgirl-fortheloveofrpattz.blogspot.com/2010/03/heres-new-moon-kiss-we-did-not-get-to.html
I got the Target version and was so disappointed when I got home and realized it didn't have the little film cell. I do think I will go and get the Walmart edition too.
I did the WalMart release party and got my Ultimate Fan Edition precisely because I knew that the Eclipse sneak peek is on there. But, I also ALWAYS planned on getting the Target edition with the deleted/extended scenes. However, I also checked youtube so I wasn't deprived until I can make it to Target later today.
Buuuuuuutttttttt.....
Here's my question. All the extended and deleted scenes I've seen DO NOT include the scene where Alice and Edward bring Bella home from Italy. We know they filmed the scene because we've seen the stills from it. Where is it?? Someone? Anyone?? I NEED THAT SCENE!!!!!
Drgnflygrl, mine didn't have the cell either. I didn't buy it for that, but feel deprived all the same.
I really do not want to buy more than one. Looks like I will be tempted to do so.
It makes me mad that Summit does this. Obviously they're going to make more money buy pitting the retailers against each other because lots of people will buy them all but I think it's unfair.
I don't know...they should just include everything on one and charge like $40. I'd buy it in a heartbeat. I just can't justify spending $80 to get all the extras. I mean, my husband's cool but he's not THAT cool. I got the Target 3 disc but haven't had a chance to watch everything yet. If it's not the best one, well I guess that's what youtube is for, right?
Still drives me crazy though.
Hey ADM!
I can't afford to buy all these dvds and I don't want to feel like I'm missing anything. Feel like I'm getting screwed...
Exactly Laura.
Drgnflygrl and ADM - did you get the two disc or the three disc from Target? I believe the cell only came with the three disc, it's inside the box on a little bit of card. You're not missing much :-)
ITA Emily & Laura,
It's all about the $$ to Summit and how much money they can squeeze out of the fans...they know we want to see it all...
I want the Borders one as well, but that would put me upwards of $75, which is really ridiculous....but I still want it! wahhhh....
The cell is def nothing you're missing...mine is of Jacob, and even if it were Rob, what the hell would I do with it? You're not missing a thing....
I got the 3-disc set from Target. It did have the film cell in it, but it's of Bella and Jacob- my least favorite characters. I wanted Edward (of course), but I'd have been happier w/ Mike than what I got! lol
I think this is calculating and greedy on Summit's part. I was very disappointed to find out I had to buy three dvd's to get all the extras I wanted. I feel like Summit just gave the Twilight fans the big middle finger. I know most of us probably paid to see New Moon at the box office more than once. I for one went six times. I have been waiting for months for the dvd to come out specifically for the deleted/extended scenes. Summit owes the Twilight fans better treatment than this.
Kate,
Thankfully I have the UK two disc version too. Looks like it has all the same extras as Annies three disc Scandinavian one!
Thanks to all who did this; it was kind of you to make the effort.
rpg--exactly--I got a jacob cel as well. feh.
Helpful chart - thanks. I also don't like the way this worked out, and it is calculated, but I don't think it was done with the specific intent of saying f.u to fans. It was to keep the retailers happy, so they would sell merchandize as well as the movie, also keeping tie-ins for the next installment. It blows, though, and I think they better offer something special for Eclipse as redemption.
I got the Target version. Mainly because of the deleted scenes. It seemed better than the Walmart one. Otherwise I may have gone with the Borders one. I just can't justify spending money on more than one. I'll just look on youtbe for the rest. But yeah... they should put everything on one ....it's just wrong. Some of the 3 disc Target versions..not all have the cell, you have to look for the sticker on the front saying so.. I got Bella at the caferteria table...meh
AP I'm sure you're right that it wasn't meant to be an f.u. but it sure felt like one and amen on hoping they redeem themselves with Eclipse. Also, does anyone know where Edward's quote "Every second I'm with you is about restraint and you're too fragile" is? Anyone who has visited Summit's New Moon website has heard it yet it's not on the deleted scenes or any of the extended scenes I have seen.
Drgnflygrl and ADM, mine didn't have the film cell either, & I did get the blu-ray 2 disc Target version. I was going to try & exchange it & see if I got a film cell in the new one.
In addition to the Target version, I ordered the Walmart version (which should come tomorrow), but somehow missed that the Borders version was different. I just thought it had the medallion thingy. Now I don't know what to do, should I buy all 3 or not? It's so ridiculous to buy all these mutliples, I really feel stupid doing it. If Summit would just put out 1 version with everything, I would buy it.
The thing that's really scary is that you know after all the movies are done, they are going to put out some kind of special collection of all of them. How many version of that will there be, & how much will it cost? I'm going to end up with 10 versions of each movie.
Marna,
ITA! Bet ya anything there will be all kinds of collector editions of the movies when the saga is over...and yes 10 versions of each movie...It's actually brilliant marketing even though it sucks for the consumer..
But, many will pay...including me..I have no will power...
I think we did quite well with the Uk two disc version we seem to have most of the stuff!
Thank God there's not much of a seletion here I wouldn't know what to buy and would probably end up buying them all!
Is there a deleted scene where they took Bella home to Charlie after Italy on any of these?
And they're probably going to do this again with Eclipse. With Twilight, I think different versions may have had things like keychains & stuff, but the only 2 different dvds were the Borders & Target versions. For NM, we've got 3 different versions, Target, Borders, & Walmart. Is Eclipse going to have 4 different versions of the dvd?
hi everyone waving you all
@Shauna- I did the same. Walmart was convienient for this busy mom of three young boys. I bought a new Twilight as well. My old one was panting and begging for mercy. LOL. I loved it when a lady and her son asked the Walmart associate for a Twilight dvd, he went to look and I heard him say, Im sorry, I just filled the shelf three minutes ago and there empty. He continured to say it's been happening all weekend. I smiled a big cheesy smile, loving the fact that our fandom rocks. Im curious what the sale numbers are.
Is it wrong that I squeeled like a fangirl because they have FINALLY started showing Remember Me trailer/TV spots over here in England?
Hey Emily!
Kat, yes I got the three disk. I really do not even want the cell. Just hate false advertising.
Hmm, Well, Maybe I'll just buy the UK version and be done with it...
I don't care about the cell/cel(?) or the bracelets, although my girls would probably like them, but I do want to see all scenes that were made, and I wish they could be put in the place they belong, instead of out of context.
If anyone wants the Jacob cell/cel (What IS that word, anyway???) email me your address and I will send it to the first person who asks.
Or if Gozde wants it for a giveaway (although I do not who in her right mind would want Jacob :-D )let me know, Gozde, as you get priority.
I think that this is craziness!! Needing to buy 3 DVD's from different businesses. Just to get everything. Grrr
This is a total scam. I live in Canada n don't have access to the Target n Wal-Mart DVD n it totally sucks that all the good stuff like the sneak peak n deleted scenes r only on those ones. Now i'm gonna have to buy it off of ebay @ like double the price (yeah i know im crazy) but i want the extra so bad.
U see how much i love this flippin saga! Grrrrrrrrr lol
robs--can you not order it by mail from walmart and target? i did.
@Fae Where are you???
MoTU Update!!!!
Emily, ITA!!!! I would gladly spend the $40 if it had everything, but I just can't justify buying 2 or 3 dvd's...:(
I'm pretty happy with the Walmart one, the Edward fast forward option is GENIUS! No extended or deleted scenes, but thank God for Robsessed! LOL
Thanks Theresa (& kate)....this was a great idea....
I've already purchased the Target & Walmart. And I bought the UK version too because we have a place in Europe and I'll be able to watch it there. And comparing it with your list, the UK version has everything the three U.S. versions have except 1. The Cell(I got the Bella & EDward breakup scene, btw) 2. TWilight in Forks 3. shooting in italy 4. necklace
5. red carpet & 6. webcast....
So I guess I'll be buying the Borders version, TOO! It's money well spent!
Summit, when all is said done, will probably put out a dvd box set with all 4(or5) movies, with all kinds of extra stuff we're not getting now just so we'll buy it all over again!!!
And, sadly, I probably will!
Theresa, thank you! This is very useful! I bought the Target three disc version and I am happy to say that my film cell was with B and E. I was sad to see that the extended scenes were not included and there was no "Edward Fast Forward." The deleted scenes were no great shakes. I should have gone with Walmart. But I'm not going to buy another version, sorry Summit!
Dearest Kate, Gozde and the Robsession team, I am so grateful to you for posting the extended scenes, Edward goes to Italy and the Eclipse preview from WalMart.
Just one more please? Would you please post the "Edward Fast Forward" from the Walmart version?
Thanks for everything!
I ended up with walmart and target and I'm tempted to give in and get the borders version as well. I like my film cell from target (I got carlisle volturi time period) and the water bottle and poster pack I got from going to the midnight release at walmart is fun too. I got Team Jacob water bottle, that's all my store had, did anyone else get something different, I was actually curious if they did a team bella.
Here in Spain I've bought a 3 discs special edition :o)
the Edward Fast Forward is all the Edward scenes in the movie, and it zips by all the other scenes. So there's nothing new there...it's just that the fast forwarding has been done for you. Those who don't have it aren't missing anything, just some convenience in getting to the Robward stuff! :)
Aren't there interviews on the Borders dvd that aren't on the others? I don't think I've seen any of them.
Living in Canada, I only got a 2 disc set from HMV that came with a cell (Bella & Ed in the restaurant) The Walmart version had a poster incl. with theirs and the pkg had a 3D cover. We didn't get any of the deleted/extended scenes that are on the net, or the Eclipse footage on the Walmart DVD.
Canada got ripped off after they filmed it here in our country for cheap. Not fair. Now I have to ask relatives in the US to send me a copy of the Target version
I have a crazy idea. Why don't they put everything in one box, charge us $50 for it, and ship the same thing to every store? WHY do I have to buy three different versions to get everything? Actually, I know the answer to this (Summit likes money) but DAMN!
Thank you for allowing me to vent.
They should put a Robward in the box too ;oP
@RobsDirtyGirl
If we were in the same region (this pal/ntsc thing) I could send you the 3 disc special edition from Spain. I can understand your Robsession ;o)
@Aneska77 lol that would have been very sweet of you. thnx for the thought :)
*goes to corner n pouts* Being Canadian really suck right now :(
what is the "Edward fastforward?"
@RobsDirtyGirl
You're welcome :o)
Oh, thank you RPLover, for the clarification. I thought I was missing something!
I never know what to do with the effing film cell. Got one last year for Twilight from Hot Topic (Edward and Bella dancing at the prom). So what? It's not a high quality photo? I didn't pick the cell I wanted? It's like something in a box of cracker jack.
Haven't got my Target copy yet but I thought the 3 disc one had more than mentioned on that fine comparison list.
I think the greedy bastards don't have a speck of respect, either for fans or for their product. Yeah, they should offer the same edtions everywhere, so you can grab a one, two or three disc from any store you want. Has any other film been sold this way, with such discrepancies among various retailers?
I'm still pissed off with Summit for the clusterfuck they pulled off NOT representing Remember Me properly and causing so many people to stay away.
You watch, this film--unlike any of the Twisaga, and I'm a fan too--will become a classic, once the ignorant and stupid reviewers and fans come to their bloody senses.
Frankly, the fiasco with Remember Me pisses me off far more than all this greed with NM DVDs. I'm assuming ALL of you have seen Remember Me. If not, get your asses into those theatres now, this week. And do not--I repeat--do not dare to think Edward Cullen. God, I love the crazy mixed-up vamp too, but now I love Tyler more.
And Robert is the massive talent who brought us both.
averagegirl: Squeal to your heart's content. And get everyone in your neck of the woods out there to see RM, friends, relatives, everyone. Maybe the poor thing will have more box office luck over there. Help make it happen.
I know I sound demented but I'm so pissed off at what has happened to it. To the point that I realize I'm not on a RM thread and I don't give a damn; my fingers are just flying around the keyboard.
@Dawn -
yeah, I agree - these places are just trying to ROB us by putting different things on each of them!! Pun intended.
We are such suckers to fall for their tactics but ..........it's Rob.....I want to see all I can.
I have the Target version but will probably end up getting Borders' and maybe Walmart too. I work hard for my little amount of money so it's tough to shell it out.
jessegirl
I agree on both of your points, the retailers suck for not being the same and Summit sucks for not promoting RM more.
I want him to do well with this movie
Ok which one is good then?
the walmart one or the target one??
I got the two disc original Twilight one from Amazon,
I want to get one that has deleted scenes etc.
Which one should I get?
if you are only getting one, I would go with target
Hi, I got the three disc on from target. I got the film cell with Jacob and bella during a part of the motorcycle scenes. You can't see bella's face just the back of her head. I really do not want this one at all. I wanted one of Edward. Perferablly the break up scene. But if anyone would like to trade you can email me at xdollfacektbbyx@aol.com
It is much appreciated!
And I hope all loved the versions that they got!
Post a Comment